Buying life insurance isn’t just buying a paper contract. It is buying a promise: a message to a spouse, to children, and to one’s future self that “if the worst happens, the family will be taken care of.”
That promise might need to be kept 20, 30, or even 50 years later.
In a world full of startups, spinoffs, and “disruptors,” it is tempting to go with a smaller, newer company that might offer a slightly cheaper premium or a flashier website. But when a family’s financial survival is on the line, there is a distinct advantage to choosing a company that has weathered the storms for over a century.
Choosing a top-tier, heritage company isn’t just about brand names; it’s about eliminating risk and hassle for the people who depend on the policy.
The Hidden Risk of “Small and New”
Insurance risk is usually thought of in terms of the policyholder dying. But there is another risk: the company dying.
The industry does have a safety net (State Guaranty Associations) to prevent total catastrophe, but relying on that net is not a smooth experience. When a smaller, less capitalized insurer hits a financial wall, as many did during the 2008 crisis, policies don’t just seamlessly switch over.
Choosing a smaller or struggling carrier can leave this baggage for a family:
- The “Frozen” Asset: When companies like Standard Life of Indiana failed, regulators froze assets. Cash value intended for a child’s tuition or an emergency was locked away for over a year. A large, solvent company doesn’t freeze policyholder money.
- The Administrative Nightmare: When Shenandoah Life went into receivership, policyholders spent three years in limbo. Picture beneficiaries trying to file a claim, only to find the company run by a government receiver, customer service non-existent, and the payout delayed.
- The “Spinoff” Shuffle: Small spinoffs are often sold and resold. A policy might start with “Company A,” get sold to “Company B,” and end up administered by “Company C.” Each time, the relationship with a trusted agent can be lost, logins change, and paperwork goes missing.
The Comfort of the Giants
Corebridge Financial owns and operates American General Life, which has been around for over 100 years. Corebridge was created by AIG and is still partially owned by AIG today. These companies operate with massive financial reserves designed to absorb shocks that would shatter smaller companies.
Choosing a top-tier carrier means paying for continuity.
- They Pay When It Matters: During the 2008 crisis, while smaller insurers were being liquidated, the top-rated companies were not only paying claims promptly; they were paying dividends to their policyholders.
- One-Call Resolution: A family filing a claim shouldn’t have to navigate a liquidation court. Beneficiaries should be able to call a recognizable name, speak to a professional, and receive their funds quickly.
Peace of Mind Is Worth It
A major, highly rated insurer keeps the administrative burden on a family near zero. The check clears, the agent answers the phone, and the promise made is kept without a single hiccup.
Leave a Reply